June 19, 2018  |  

SCHOOL’S OUT: Six-Month Report Card Gives Trump-GOP Tax Cuts Failing Grades

Link to Report Card PDF

ATF Releases Report on How Tax-Cut Law Benefits Corporations and the Wealthy, Not Workers and Families, and Jeopardizes Health Care Coverage for Many

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Marking the six-month anniversary of the Trump-GOP tax cuts that were signed into law December 22, 2017, Americans for Tax Fairness today released a Six-Month Report Card showing how the tax cuts have affected employers, workers, families and health insurance premiums both nationally and in individual states. An analysis backing up the report cards grades is here. Not surprisingly, the massive Trump-GOP tax cuts, which cost $1.9 trillion, get a failing grade in each of five categories – fairness, increasing worker pay, overall cost, protecting healthcare and sharing the wealth.

Along with the report card, ATF released a video and reports for 17 states showing how the tax cuts are primarily benefiting wealthy corporations and their shareholders and failing to raise wages for employees. A second report for the same states shows how the tax-cut law is causing health insurance premiums to spike throughout the country, and many state residents will lose their health care coverage because the tax law repealed a key provision in the Affordable Care Act.

On a six month report card, Trump-GOP tax cuts get a failing grade.

“President Trump and the GOP promised that these huge tax cuts would primarily help the middle class, give workers a $4,000 raise, and lead to major business investment,” said Frank Clemente, executive director of Americans for Tax Fairness. “It’s now been six months since the tax cut law was passed, and none of those promises have come true. The law gets an ‘F’ for failing to deliver.”

Key findings from the ATF report show that:

  • Although President Trump promised the average worker would see a $4,000 pay raise due to the tax cuts, only 4% of workers so far are getting a bonus or wage hike.
  • Only 402 of the nation’s six million employers have announced any plans to share their tax cuts with employees through bonuses or wage hikes. The total is estimated at $7 billion so far. But that pales in comparison to the $77 billion in tax cuts that just 156 corporations are getting this year.
  • Corporations are giving huge windfalls to their CEOs and wealthy shareholders in the form of stock buybacksas they own most stock. Corporations have announced $484 billion in stock buybacks since the tax law was passed. That’s 69 times more than the $7 billioncorporations have promised workers through one-time bonuses and wage hikes.
  • Despite the promise that the tax cuts would increase wages, the government reported last week that in the last year average hourly wages for four out of five workers in the private sector have gone down after inflation.

In addition, by effectively repealing the individual mandate in the Affordable Care Act, the tax-cut law will cause:

  • 13 million Americans to lose health care coverage by 2025 [CBO].
  • ACA insurance premiums to spike by 10%, on average, most years for the next decade.

“The Trump-GOP tax cuts are a disaster for workers, families and for health care coverage,” Clemente said. “First, the law repeals a key part of the Affordable Care Act, which will spike insurance premiums for many struggling families and older Americans near retirement age. Next, the tax cuts are jacking up the deficit giving conservatives in Congress an excuse to slash Medicare and Medicaid, and even Social Security.”

Despite the failure of the tax cut law to live up to the promises by its supporters, President Trump and members of his party are proposing a second round of tax cuts for the wealthy that could cost another $1 trillion. The resulting increase in the national debt will embolden conservatives to demand even more cuts to health care, education, nutrition services, housing and more. A letter from 130 national organizations opposed to these tax cuts is here.